City council reverses direction, funds EBCC State Supreme Court appeal

In a surprising turnaround at the Bellevue city council meeting Tuesday evening, the council voted 4-2 to support funding an appeal to the Washington Supreme Court.

The appeal was proposed by the East Bellevue Community Council after that body lost its case in the King County Court of Appeals to Puget Sound Energy.

The community council is challenging the ruling on a Puget Sound Energy project focused on elevated high voltage transmission lines on a route through its jurisdiction. The project is a 2.9-mile long high-voltage power line intended to shore up electrical reliability between the Lake Hills and Phantom Lake substations.

The East Bellevue Community Council believes the route selected for the project an unnecessarily complicated one which cuts through its jurisdiction on an urban boulevard. Bill Capron, community council chair, said it still had a good case.

“If they city denies our funding, they take the place of the state Supreme Court,” he said. “We only wanted $7,000. I know every tax dollar matters, but when governments stop putting zeroes behind numbers because thousands are so inconsequential, we don’t think that’s much to ask for.”

The community council initially won the case in the court of Judge William Downing, where the jurisdiction of that council was affirmed. It subsequently lost the case on appeal.

Capron asked the council to consider granting the legal funding, as the community council’s legal counsel stated she could not accept crowd-funded money.

“We would do that if we could, but that’s not an option for us,” he said.

Last week, the Bellevue city council voted 4-2 to put a resolution on Tuesday’s agenda which would have stated the appeals funding was not a necessary expense.

In the week between, city staff drafted up two resolutions, one denying the funding as unnecessary and one approving it as necessary, just in case council decided to approve funding. Mayor John Stokes and Councilmember Lynne Robinson changed their votes.

The appeal itself would cost approximately $7,000 even to prepare and file, and an additional $20,000 should the court accept the case for review — far from a guarantee.

Deputy Mayor John Chelminiak was not happy with the changes tides on the council.

“There is no other option. It’s very clear in the report from [Engineering consulting firm Exponent] that the concept of looping does not solve the issue,” he said.

Citizens had proposed looping back high voltage lines through existing power substations to better protect the grid in lieu of the Lake Hills project. Exponent recommended three lines going to each substation, while the substation in question currently has one.

“That’s the resiliency we need in a major storm,” Chelminiak said. “It’s a critical health and safety situation. I’m going to vote no tonight. I’m not going to vote to waste money.”

Councilmember Kevin Wallace was the other vote denying the funding.

Capron has reached out to legal counsel Kathleen Haggard to prepare the briefs. The community council has until March 3 to file the briefs.

In consideration of how we voice our opinions in the modern world, we’ve closed comments on our websites. We value the opinions of our readers and we encourage you to keep the conversation going.

Please feel free to share your story tips by emailing

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) We reserve the right to edit letters, but if you keep yours to 300 words or less, we won’t ask you to shorten it.

More in News

Free masks at the Bellevue Salvation Army. Courtesy photo
Free mask pickup for Bellevue residents

New dates and times for mask distribution this week

Nurse Sylvia Keller, pictured with Gov. Jay Inslee, is on the front lines of the COVID-19 battle in Yakima County. Courtesy photo
Governor doubles down on mask rules

Inslee: Starting July 7, businesses do not serve those who do not wear a mask

State Capitol Building in Olympia. File photo
Politicians get pay raises, state workers get furloughs

A citizens panel approved the hikes in 2019. Unable to rescind them, lawmakers look to donate their extra earnings.

Construction begins for Downtown Park entrance

The previously delayed entryway project is expected to be finished early 2021

Human remains in West Seattle identified

Bags of body parts were found in a suitcase along a West Seattle beach on June 19.

According to King County’s Mental Illness and Drug Dependency (MIDD) annual report, Seattle had the highest rate of people using services at 36 percent of the total, followed by 31 percent from South King County, 18 percent from the greater Eastside, and 7 percent from north county including Shoreline. Courtesy image
Drug courts, officer de-escalation programs impacted by MIDD cuts

The fund provides money for mental illness and drug dependency programs across King County.

Summer vehicle travel projected to decrease this year

Traffic this summer will likely be lighter across Washington state than previous… Continue reading

Governor Jay Inslee smiles and laughs Sept. 3, 2019, during a speech at the Lynnwood Link Extension groundbreaking in Lynnwood. A Thurston County judge ruled he exceeded his authority when he vetoed single sentences in the state transportation budget in 2019. (Olivia Vanni / Herald file)
Judge invalidates Gov. Inslee’s veto in roads budget

Lawmakers said the governor crossed a constitutional line.

King County cases among younger adults drives increase in COVID-19 numbers

Over half of all new cases are among people ages 20-39

Most Read