Alternatives to a full-blown house appraisal


  • Tuesday, September 23, 2008 5:08pm
  • Business


Scripps Howard News Service

In the quest to make home loans cheaper and quicker, lenders don’t order labor-intensive, full appraisals as often as they used to. A lender might request anything from a full-blown appraisal to a “drive-by” inspection by a real-estate broker. Thanks to computer technology, some home equity loans don’t require a visit to the house at all.

You probably won’t have much say in how the lender verifies the property’s value, but it doesn’t hurt to ask.

“I’m sure if a customer says to the bank, ‘I’d like to have this as cost-effective as possible,’ they’ll try to order the least expensive appraisal they can,” appraiser Allan Bredice says.

Home purchases and refinances almost always require at least some type of appraisal conducted by a licensed appraiser, although they don’t always require an interior inspection. It’s the world of home equity loans where the computer has made the most inroads.

In many purchases and in some equity loans, a licensed appraiser conducts what is called a complete summary appraisal. The appraiser inspects the inside and outside of the house, takes pictures, looks at three comparable nearby properties and produces a report with a location map, a drawing of the house’s layout and supporting details to justify the appraiser’s opinion of the house’s value.

To save time and money, the mortgage industry came up with the “2055 form,” in which a licensed appraiser prepares a condensed analysis. A computer program decides whether or not a 2055 form appraisal requires an interior inspection.

When it comes to home equity loans, licensed appraisers aren’t always involved in the process. Occasionally a lender will order a BPO, a broker price opinion, in which a real-estate broker looks at a house and, based on the broker’s knowledge of home sales in the neighborhood, estimates the value.

After BPOs comes the world of high technology, where experts extol AVMs and skeptics warn about GIGO, garbage in, garbage out.

AVMs, or automated valuation models, are computer programs that estimate house values based on factors such as the size of the building and the lot, location, amenities and sales prices of nearby houses.

In a way, an appraiser is doing the same thing in a much cruder fashion.

Lenders mostly use AVMs to support home equity loans for relatively small amounts and with low loan-to-value ratios.

Some believes lenders will come to use AVMs for most purchases, too at least for typical properties. In other words, not a house on a cliff overlooking the Pacific, but for the typical house in a big subdivision where values tend to be concentrated, or a condo where the floor or the view is the differentiating factor.

In consideration of how we voice our opinions in the modern world, we’ve closed comments on our websites. We value the opinions of our readers and we encourage you to keep the conversation going.

Please feel free to share your story tips by emailing

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) We reserve the right to edit letters, but if you keep yours to 300 words or less, we won’t ask you to shorten it.

More in Business

Sound Publishing operates the following titles in King County: Federal Way Mirror, Auburn Reporter, Kent-Covington Reporter, Renton Reporter, Enumclaw Courier-Herald, Kirkland Reporter, Bellevue Reporter, Snoqualmie Valley Record, Issaquah Reporter, Redmond Reporter, Bothell-Kenmore Reporter, Mercer Island Reporter and the Vashon-Maury Island Beachcomber.
Bellevue Reporter to suspend print publication

As the coronavirus pandemic continues to rapidly evolve across the globe, the… Continue reading

COVID-19 gathering restriction delays funerals

For one funeral home owner, the confusion came to a head after a recent service.

For sale sign hanging in front of house. File photo
Open houses close due to coronavirus concerns

Northwest Multiple Listing Service halts large group home tours amid pandemic.

A Boeing 777X during a taxi test. (Boeing Co.)
Companywide, Boeing reports 11 confirmed cases of COVID-19

Boeing will equip more employees to work remotely, but for now factory workers will stay on the line.

A shot of downtown Kirkland. Samantha St. John of the city’s chamber of commerce said that Kirkland’s business community is likely being more detrimentally affected than others on the Eastside due to the city’s often being deemed the epicenter of the coronavirus epidemic. Blake Peterson/staff photo
‘We’re just kind of in limbo’: Eastside businesses feeling significant economic effects amid coronavirus pandemic

Eastside chamber representatives discuss the states of their business communities.

Bellevue skyline. File photo
Amid coronavirus concerns, Eastside cities are taking preventative steps

Most Eastside cities are following recommendations from county officials.

A flight takes off at SeaTac International Airport. Photo courtesy Port of Seattle
Port of Seattle, airlines respond to COVID-19 with new health measures

Changes at Sea-Tac Airport include more hand sanitizer, training for biohazard cleaning.

Mitchell Atencio/Staff Photo
                                A customer orders a drink at the drive-thru of Megan’s Coffee Corner in Bellevue on Feb. 25.
Megan’s Coffee Corner closing at the end of Feb., will be replaced by Starbucks in the summer

The local shop, which started in 2001, will close and be replaced by a drive-thru Starbucks this summer.

With Mount Baker and Jetty Island in the distance, a container ship approaches the Port of Everett. (Port of Everett photo)
Senate Dems: $5 million to help businesses disrupted by coronavirus

Overseas port closures hurt WA companies that depend on international shipping.

Robo investment advice has drawbacks | Business advice column

A monthly business advice column by a Mercer Island financial adviser.

Pinnacle Development proposed two 26 story buildings for the downtown Bellevue area

The proposals are for mixed-use buildings that include residential, shopping and other facilities.

Photo by Claire Albright
                                The Bellevue Ice Rink has various events throughout the season, such as stroller skate days, free skate lessons, Husky Skate Day, and Jedi Skate Night. These help switch up the typical skating experience.
Time to say goodbye to Bellevue Ice Rink for season

Taking a look behind-the-scenes of the Bellevue Ice Rink as the break-down process begins